Bewitched
I Don't Want to Be a Toad, I Want to Be a Butterfly
TV Flash files “I Don't Want to Be a Toad, I Want to Be a Butterfly” as hour 151 of 254 in the TV Flash guide — Bewitched (1964–1972) on ABC, season 5, episode 11, aired 1968-12-12, 30 min.
From the desk
How this hour is filed
This leaf is S05E11: listed hour 151 of 254 in the Bewitched guide, hour 11 of 30 in season 5. It aired 1968-12-12 (30 min). The listed hour before it is “Samantha Loses Her Voice” (S05E10). Next is “Weep No More My Willow” (S05E12).
Catalog log
Broadcast listing — not a TV Flash recap.
Tabitha goes to pre-school for the first time and meets Amy, a classmate. When the teacher groups the children in animal groups, Amy gets chosen to be a toad in the toad group, but she wants to be in a butterfly group. Tabitha misunderstands her request and actually turns her into a butterfly! Samantha, who has been watching the whole thing through the window, chases Amy the butterfly all around the city and catches her so Tabitha can change her back.
Viewer FAQ
Where does I Don't Want to Be a Toad, I Want to Be a Butterfly sit in the Bewitched guide?
S05E11 is listed hour 151 of 254 — hour 11 of 30 in season 5, season 5 episode 11.
When did Bewitched S05E11 air?
I Don't Want to Be a Toad, I Want to Be a Butterfly aired 1968-12-12 and is listed at 30 minutes.
Why do Darrin Stephens look different after a certain season?
Dick York played Darrin through season 5. Dick Sargent took over in season 6 after York left because of back injuries. The show did not pause to explain the face. Audiences still notice.
In the series
Why this series still plays
Watch the twitch as a fashion cue: Samantha's suburban chic smuggling power into a pretty house. The recast is the scandal; the look is the argument — magic as silhouette, marriage as costume change, chiffon doing the plot.
She twitches, and the living room rearranges itself — chiffon still falling, blonde still behaving, the house in Westport already a set decoration for a secret. That is not a special effect. That is a silhouette doing the plot. Bewitched, 1964 on ABC, is glamour as suburban camouflage: Samantha Stephens in perfect hostess clothes, a nose twitch as the only jewelry that matters, and a marriage that keeps asking her to dress like she is not a witch. Style is the argument. If you only track the gags, you are…
Filed against
- Elizabeth Montgomery as Samantha Stephens
Elizabeth Montgomery nose-twitched suburban magic into existence as Samantha Stephens on Bewitched — fantasy sitcom that smuggled change into a pretty house. Grace under Darrin-recast chaos made her 1960s TV royalty. TV Flash still…
- Dick York as Darrin Stephens
Dick York was the first Darrin Stephens on Bewitched — mortal panic in a gray suit beside Elizabeth Montgomery's twitch, five seasons before a back injury forced the recast the living room never forgot. TV Flash files him as the original…
- Dick Sargent as Darrin Stephens
Dick Sargent inherited Darrin Stephens on Bewitched from season six — the recast the living room clocked like a missing ring. Same gray-suit mortal, same marriage to Samantha's twitch: a hard swap after Dick York's back could no longer…
- Agnes Moorehead as Endora
Agnes Moorehead glowered and glittered as Endora on Bewitched — the mother-in-law as glamorous magical menace in 1960s fantasy sitcom form. Radio and film pedigree made every eye-roll land like a spell. TV Flash crowns her the original…